Internal Audit Practices and Their Effectiveness in Local Government: A Comparative Sector Analysis using a systematic review
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.51137/wrp.ijarbm.804Keywords:
Internal Audit, Local Government, Effectiveness, Governance, Public Sector, Audit Practices, Risk Management, Auditor Independence.Abstract
The investigations into effectiveness of current internal audit practices within local government is mandatory given deficiencies in their value. Using PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) methodology, a systematic review of 77 peer reviewed articles, reports, and case studies published between 2015 and 2024 was conducted. The analysis focused on audit planning, risk assessment, control evaluation and reporting practices of local governments. The findings indicate that while internal audit practice’s significant role in influencing organisational effectiveness, issues such as inconsistencies in compliance with audit standards, lack of sufficient resources and limited independence hinder their effectiveness. Notably, local governments facing financial distress display a weaker internal audit process, resulting in systematically sub‐optimal fraud detection and weak compliance oversight. Standardisation, resource allocation and stakeholder communication are areas where gaps in current practices need to be addressed to enhance transparency. The study emphasis need to utilise technology driven solutions such as data analytics in enhancing audit efficiency, increasing legislative reforms of audit independence and capacity-building initiatives of internal auditors and contributes to the discussion on how to improve the practices of internal audit in local government in order to enhance local government’s contribution to sustainable governance across the sectors. This research also contributes towards a conceptual framework to address the interface between internal audit practices and their effectiveness.
References
Abdullah, K.H. (2021) Mapping of marine safety publications using VOSviewer. ASM Sci. J. 2021, 16, 1–9
Ackermann, C. & Marx, B. (2016). Internal audit risk management in metropolitan municipalities. Risk Governance and Control: Financial Markets & Institutions.
Aikins, A. E., Mensah, J. V., & Kumi-Kyereme, A. (2024). Examining internal audit process of selected local governments in the central region of Ghana. Journal of Public Administration, 32(1), 77-89.
Ali, A. (2016). Change in internal auditing practice: Evolution, constraints and ingenious solutions.
Almodallah, Y.I., Shahimi, S. & Azmi, A.A.C. (2023). Building a conceptual model for internal auditing: the perspective of absorptive capacity theory.Advanced International Journal of Banking, Accounting and Finance.
Amhalhal, A.M.A., Anchor, J., Tipi, N.S. & Elgazzar, S. (2021). The impact of contingency fit on organisational performance: an empirical study.International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management.
Angioi, M. & Hiller, C.E. (2023). Systematic Literature Reviews.
Appiah, M. K., Amaning, N., Tettevi, P. K., Owusu, D. F., & Ware, E. O. (2024). Internal audit effectiveness as a boon to public procurement performance: a multi-mediation model. Journal of Accounting & Finance, 18(3), 112-124.
Arvanitis, C.D. (2024). Systematic literature review in five steps.Berkeley Program in Law & Economics.
Azizah, T.N., Evitasari, P.A. & Kustiwi, I.A. (2023). Peran Strategis Internal Audit dalam Meningkatkan Tata Kelola Perusahaan. Jurnal Ekonomi, Bisnis dan Manajemen.
Bacha, S. & Al-sagheer, N.H.A. (2024). Internal Audit, Strategic Risks and Corporate Financial Distress.Journal of ecohumanism.
Badara, M.S. (2017). The Relevant of Contingency Theory and Stewardship Theory on the Internal Audit Research.
Barasa, K.S. (2015). Statistical Analysis of the Role of Internal Audit in Promoting Good Governance in Public Institutions in Kenya.Journal of Investment Management.
Boufounou, P. V., Eriotis, N., Kounadeas, T., Argyropoulos, P., & Poulopoulos, J. (2024). Enhancing internal control mechanisms in local government organisations: A crucial step towards mitigating corruption and ensuring economic development. Local Government Studies, 50(4), 455-474.
Brignardello‐Petersen, R., Santesso, N. & Guyatt, G. (2024). Systematic reviews of the literature: an introduction to current methods.American Journal of Epidemiology.
Bryson, J.M., Crosby, B.C. & Bloomberg, L. (2015). Creating Public Value in Practice: Advancing the Common Good in a Multi-Sector, Shared-Power, No-One-Wholly-in-Charge World.
Budiandru, B. (2024). The Impact of Internal Audit Effectiveness, Risk Management Practices, and Organisational Culture on Financial Performance.Sahoe gwahag nonchong.
Chen, S. & Wang, S. (2015). A Contingency Theory of Internal Reorganisation: Risk and Output Management.Social Science Research Network.
Coetzee, P. (2016). Contribution of internal auditing to risk management. International Journal of Public Sector Management.
Coetzee, P., & Erasmus, L. J. (2024). Drivers of stakeholders’ view of internal audit effectiveness: Management versus audit committee. International Journal of Auditing, 21(1), 33-44.
Dallagnol, E.C., Portulhak, H. & Peixe, B.C.S. (2022). How is public value associated with accountability? A systematic literature review.Public Money & Management.
Darma, I.G.M., Mastika, I.K., Karyadi, H. & Prayitno, H. (2024). Regional Governance Based on Public Value: Study in East Ogan Komering Ulu Regency Government, Indonesia.RGSA:
Gamayuni, R.R. (2018). The effect of internal auditor competence and objectivity, and management support on effectiveness of internal audit function and financial reporting quality implications at local government.International Journal of Economic Policy in Emerging Economies.
Garavan, T & O'Brien, F (2024), Contingency theory. in A Guide too Key Theories for Human Resource Management Research. Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd., pp. 67-72
George, A. & Meela, D. (2024). Determinants of Internal Audit Effectiveness in Local Government Authorities (LGAs): Evidence from Morogoro Region of Tanzania. Asian journal of economics, business and accounting.
Gough, D. & Richardson, M. (2024). Systematic Reviews. In Advanced Research Methods for Psychology 2(16). Routledge
Igibayeva, Z. 2020. The Impact of Internal Public Audit on the Use of Public Resources.
Karagiorgos, A., Stamatis, S., Plioska, P., & Koutri, O. (2024). Audit in the service of revenue increase: A tool for boards and committees of local authorities. Public Finance Review, 42(6), 784-805.
Karikari, A.M., Tettevi, P.K., Amaning, N., Ware, E.O. & Kwarteng, C.O. (2022). Modeling the implications of internal audit effectiveness on value for money and sustainable procurement performance: An application of structural equation modeling.
Krille, C. 2020. Methods of the Systematic Literature Review.
Kurniawan, T., Bukit, R. & Erwin, K. (2023). The Factors Influencing the Risk Based Internal Audit in Improving the Effectiveness of Internal Audit.International journal of social science and business.
Kurniawati, K. (2017). Pendekatan audit internal berbasis risiko (risk based internal auditing) untuk mendukung peranan baru audit internal.
Lam, N.T.H. (2022). Factors affecting the effectiveness of internal audit.International Journal of scientific research and management.
Meynhardt, T., Brieger, S.A., Strathoff, P., Anderer, S., Bäro, A., Hermann, C., Kollat, J., Neumann, P., Bartholomes, S. & Gomez, P. (2017). Public Value Performance: What Does It Mean to Create Value in the Public Sector?
Nassou, Y. and Bennani, Z. (2024) “Contingency Theory in Management: Conceptual Phases and Strategic Link with Performance Measurement Systems”, European Journal of Arts, Humanities and Social Sciences, 1(3), pp. 183-187.
Ngcobo, P. & Malefane, S.R. (2017). Internal controls, governance and audit outcomes: Case study of a South African municipality.
Nugraha, A.P. & Soewarno, N. (2024). An Evaluation on the Implementation of Management Control in Industrial Companies According to Contingency Theory.Jurnal aplikasi manajemen.
Page, M.J., McKenzie, J.E., Bossuyt, P.M., Boutron, I., Hoffmann, T.C., Mulrow, C.D., Tetzlaff, J.M., Akl, E.A., Brennan, S.E., Chou, R., Glanville, J., Grimshaw, J.M., Hróbjartsson, A., Lalu, M.M., Li, T., Loder, E.W., Mayo-Wilson, E., McDonald, S., McGuinness, L.A., Patel, S., Thakur, R. & Das, S. (2021). The role of technology in modernizing internal audit practices in local government: A study of emerging trends. Government Financial Management Review, 41(3), pp. 249-263.
Pertiwi, R.M., Wibowo, W.A.P., Widiyaningsih, I., Mardiah, R. & Sukandani, Y. (2024). Peran Auditor Internal dalam Consulting Perusahaan. Jurnal Kendali Akuntansi.
Politis, Y. (2018). A risk-based internal audit approach for the public sector: evidence from Greece.PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. BMJ, 372, p.n71. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.n71
Puttick, G. (2020). Principles and Practice of Auditing in South Africa. Cape Town: Juta.
Redmond, J. (2020). The relevance and impact of audit practices in local government settings. Public Sector Accounting Review, 15(2), 89–104
Rahmasari, A. & Setiawan, D. (2022). Maturity of Internal Control System, the Capability of Internal Auditors, and Performance Accountability in Local Governments. Jurnal tata kelola & akuntabilitas keuangan negara.
Rampai, T.E. (2024). The organisational needs and future expectations of public sector internal auditors.
Ratmono, D. & Darsono, D. (2022). Effectiveness of internal audit in local governments: The moderating role of internal and external auditors’ relations. Revista de Gestão Social e Ambiental.
Roussy, M., Barbe, O. & Raimbault, S. (2020). Internal audit: from effectiveness to organisational significance. Managerial Auditing Journal.
Sahari, S.B., Jakpar, S.B. & Balia, S.S.B. (2023). The role of internal audits on the performance of local government administration: evidence from indonesia.Public Policy and Administration, 22(4): 578–593.
Schillemans, T., Twist, M. van, Steen, M. van der & Jong, I. de. (2018). New development: Breaking out or hanging on? Internal audit in government.Public Money & Management.
Shala, B., Prebreza, A. and Ramosaj, B. (2021) The Contingency Theory of Management as a Factor of Acknowledging the Leaders-Managers of Our Time Study Case: The Practice of the Contingency Theory in the Company Avrios. Open Access Library Journal, 8, 1-20
Shonhadji, N. & Maulidi, A. (2020). Is it suitable for your local governments?: A contingency theory-based analysis on the use of internal control in thwarting white-collar crime.Journal of Financial Crime.
Soh, W., Antonacopoulou, E.P., Rigg, C. & Bento, R.F. (2022). Embedding a ‘Reflexive Mindset’: Lessons from Reconfiguring the Internal Auditing Approach.Academy of Management Learning and Education.
Sutaryo, S. & Anto, A.T. (2023). The effectiveness of government internal auditor: evidence from Indonesia.International Journal of Accounting, Auditing and Performance Evaluation.
Sutaryo, S., Sahari, S., Jakpar, S. & Balia, S.S. (2022). Internal audit function and public service quality: evidence from indonesian local governments.Public Administration Issues.
Tackie, G., Marfo-Yiadom, E. & Achina, S.O. (2016). Determinants of Internal Audit Effectiveness in Decentralized Local Government Administrative Systems.The International Journal of Business and Management.
The Institute of Internal Auditors (2024) 'Global Internal Audit Standards'. Available at: https://www.theiia.org/en/standards/2024-standards/global-internal-audit-standards/
Tsai, W. H., Chen, H. C., Chang, J. C., & Lee, H. L. (2024). The Internal Audit Performance: The Effectiveness of ERM and IT Environments. Journal of Accounting Research, 23(1), 66-79
Tušek, B. & Barišić, I. (2016). Internal Audit Activities as a Support to Governance Processes.
Van der Merwe, A., & Erasmus, P. D. (2018). "Challenges in Public Sector Auditing: A Focus on Local Government," South African Journal of Accounting Research, 32(1), pp. 25-45.
Vashdi, D.R., Uster, A., Vigoda-Gadot, E. & Mizrahi, M. (2022). Is Auditing Worth the Effort? The Impact of Internal Auditing on Local Fiscal Outcomes. Public Performance & Management Review. 45(2), 141–160. https://doi.org/10.1080/15309576.2021.1987654
Višić, M. (2022). Connecting puzzle pieces: Systematic literature review method in the social sciences.Sociologija.
Wahhab, A.M.A. & Oshba, A.M. (2024). Examine the Relationship Between the Professional Competency of IA and the Effectiveness of RM in Improving Compliance in Iraq’s Public Organisation. Technium Social Sciences Journal.
Younas, A. & Veerasamy, R. 2024. Exploratory Study on the Importance of Internal Control in Auditing. International journal of academic research in business & social sciences.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Eugene L. Assegaai (Author)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
