Publication Ethics Policy
All journals published by Wohllebe & Ross (www.wr-publishing.org) follow the principles and ethical standards of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) at every stage of the publication process. This policy applies to all of these journals. Where a provision depends on a journal's individual setup (for example, article processing charges, special issues, or reviewer recognition), it applies only if the journal has that setup; the details are stated on the journal's own website. In this policy, "CE" refers to the Chief Editor of the respective journal.
1. Responsibilities of Editors
1.1 Initial Screening of Submissions
Every submission is first assessed by the CE and undergoes a plagiarism check (see the section on plagiarism screening and consequences of misconduct). Unless the CE rejects the manuscript immediately because of ethical concerns, plagiarism issues, or a lack of fit with the journal's scope, the CE assigns it to a handling editor, who manages the review process.
1.2 Selection of Reviewers
Researchers, clinicians, and professionals with relevant expertise may be invited to take part in the peer review process. The editor verifies the identity of each reviewer.
Authors cannot suggest reviewers. The selection of suitable reviewers rests solely with the editors, who take care to avoid conflicts of interest. Authors may, however, ask for reviewers with conflicts of interest to be excluded, provided such requests are reasonable and do not hinder a smooth review process.
1.3 Editorial Decisions
Editorial decisions are made by the handling editor on the basis of the reviewer reports and the following criteria:
- Acceptance: the topic fits the journal's focus, no technical errors have been identified, the level of English is acceptable, and neither editors nor reviewers have raised ethical concerns.
- Revision: the conditions for acceptance are only partly met, but the remaining issues can be resolved through minor adjustments.
- Rejection: the conditions for acceptance are not met and the remaining issues cannot be resolved through revision, or ethical concerns have been confirmed.
A manuscript is accepted only once all conditions for acceptance have been fulfilled.
1.4 Revisions and Disagreements with Reviewers
An editor checks uploaded revisions to determine whether the reviewers' comments have been addressed. Authors who disagree with the reviewers' comments should always contact the CE, who will examine the manuscript and the review in question and take appropriate action, for example by assigning an additional reviewer.
1.5 Ethical Concerns, Appeals, and Complaints
The CE is the point of contact for ethical concerns, appeals, and complaints. The only exception are complaints about misconduct by the CE, which should be addressed to the Executive Editor. Subject to the appeal procedure below, the CE bears ultimate responsibility for final decisions on the acceptance, rejection, correction, and retraction of articles.
Authors may appeal an editorial decision by sending a reasoned request to the CE. The appeal is assessed by an editor who was not involved in the original decision. If the CE made the original decision, the appeal is handled by the Executive Editor.
Anyone raising an ethical concern should contact the CE promptly, who will then initiate an investigation. In doing so, the CE may contact the authors' institutions, employers, and funding agencies, involve other editors, or seek independent advice from other journals or institutions. Based on the outcome, the CE decides whether an article is to be corrected or retracted.
1.6 Updates to Published Articles
1.6.1 Minor Corrections
Minor errors discovered by the authors after publication that do not affect the article's scientific findings (such as typos, misspelled names, or incorrect email addresses) are handled as silent corrections. This means the document is corrected and republished without further notice. The relevant literature databases are informed and asked to reflect the corrections in their records.
1.6.2 Correction of Substantive Errors
Errors that affect the interpretation of the findings but do not invalidate them are corrected through a published correction notice (corrigendum) that is linked to the original article. The corrected article is marked accordingly. Comments and concerns about published articles can be sent to the CE and are handled as described in the section on ethical concerns, appeals, and complaints.
1.6.3 Retractions
Retractions serve to correct the scholarly literature. They are reserved for seriously flawed articles, namely articles that:
- report unethical research
- involve plagiarism
- present unreliable results (due to miscalculation, experimental errors, or fabricated or falsified data)
- cite non-existent sources, including references hallucinated by AI tools
- publish findings without proper attribution of sources or without permission to republish
Retracted articles remain on the journal's article page but are clearly marked as retracted, and the reasons for the retraction are stated. In addition, a retraction notice linking to the retracted article is published in the next available issue.
1.6.4 Removal of Articles
In extremely rare cases, namely when an article is defamatory or unlawful or might pose a serious risk to the general public, it is removed from the article page. The article's metadata remain published, but the body text is replaced by an explanation of why the article has been removed.
1.7 Conflicts of Interest and Confidentiality of Editors
Editors must not handle a manuscript if they have a conflict of interest with the authors, their institutions, or the research (for example, through collaboration, shared affiliation, or personal or financial relationships). In such cases, the CE assigns the manuscript to another editor. Editors treat all submissions and review materials as confidential and do not use unpublished information for their own purposes. The rules on the use of AI in peer review apply to editors accordingly.
1.8 Submissions by Editors and Editorial Board Members
Manuscripts submitted by the CE or by a member of the Editorial Board are handled by another editor without a conflict of interest, who selects the reviewers and makes the decision. If the CE is an author, the Executive Editor assigns the handling editor. Submitting editors have no access to the review process of their own manuscripts. Otherwise, these manuscripts follow the standard procedure.
Articles with at least one author who is an editor, Editorial Board member, or reviewer of the journal make up no more than 25% of any issue. For journals that publish continuously without issues, this limit applies to the articles published in a calendar year.
1.9 Special Issues and Guest Editors
If a journal publishes special issues or conference proceedings, the following applies. Special issues must fall within the journal's scope, and the CE remains responsible for their content. Guest editors are approved by the CE after a check of their credentials and are overseen by the CE or a designated Editorial Board member. Articles in special issues and conference proceedings undergo the same double-anonymized peer review by external reviewers as regular articles and are labelled as part of the special issue. Manuscripts by guest editors, and manuscripts in which a guest editor has a conflict of interest, are handled by an editor independent of the special issue. Manuscripts by guest editors make up no more than 25% of the articles in a special issue.
2. Responsibilities of Authors
2.1 Criteria for Authorship
Authors are individuals who have made a substantial contribution to the submitted work, for example to its conception and design, to the acquisition, analysis, and interpretation of data, to drafting the article, or to making essential revisions to it. Every author can be held accountable for the work and its final published form. The authors' names appear on the first page of the article and in the bio sections.
2.2 Order of Authors
All authors must jointly agree on authorship and the order of authors before submitting the manuscript. All authors must be listed. Contributors who are not authors, such as translators, proofreaders, or layout editors, may be named in the acknowledgements section of the PDF version of the article.
The order of authors may be changed until the manuscript is accepted. To do so, the corresponding author must submit a request to the editor and provide a justification for the change. Once a manuscript has been accepted, no changes are possible.
2.3 Confirmation by Authors
By submitting a manuscript, all authors confirm that they are aware of the journal's ethical guidelines, agree with them, and commit to complying with them. It is further assumed that all authors have read the submitted manuscript and agree with its content.
2.4 The Corresponding Author
Each submission must have exactly one corresponding author. The corresponding author is the principal contact for editorial correspondence and is referred to as the "principal contact" on the journal platform. The journal staff contact the corresponding author for all editorial correspondence, and the corresponding author is responsible for the accuracy of the metadata of all authors entered on the journal platform.
If the journal charges Article Processing Charges (APCs), the corresponding author receives the invoice and is responsible for its timely payment. Whether a journal charges APCs, and any applicable fees or waivers, is stated on the journal's Submissions page. Author fees and fee waivers have no influence on editorial decisions.
The corresponding author also receives the copy-edited and formatted proof, checks it carefully, and takes responsibility for any remaining typos or incorrect author data, such as misspelled names or incorrect affiliations. Finally, the corresponding author must be reachable by email for the journal staff and respond promptly.
2.5 Originality, Permissions, and Licensing
All articles published by Wohllebe & Ross appear under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0). The authors warrant that the submission is original and that they are its authors. Where the submission includes text passages, figures, data, or other material from the work of others, the authors have obtained all necessary permissions.
2.6 Conflicts of Interest
Conflicts of interest must be declared at the end of the manuscript. These include research grants, paid or unpaid personal or institutional relationships, and personal relationships with individuals involved in the publication process.
2.7 Plagiarism, Duplicate Submission, and Data Integrity
Plagiarism, including self-plagiarism, is not acceptable. Plagiarism means copying text word for word, or using the ideas or concepts of others, without correctly citing the source. False data (whether invented or modified) are likewise not acceptable.
Manuscripts must not have been published previously and must not be under consideration by another journal at the same time. Reusing substantial parts of one's own published work without disclosure is treated as self-plagiarism. Posting a preprint before submission does not count as prior publication.
2.8 Research Involving Human Participants or Animals
Experimental research involving humans must have been approved by an appropriate ethics committee and must comply with the Declaration of Helsinki (2013). Research involving animals must have been approved by an appropriate ethics committee and must comply with applicable national and institutional regulations.
Authors include an ethics statement in the manuscript naming the approving committee and the approval number. Where local regulations do not require ethics approval (for example, for anonymous surveys), authors state this in the ethics statement and explain why.
Study participants included in a manuscript must be protected and must not be identifiable. Authors are therefore responsible for removing any information that could allow a participant to be identified, such as clinical images and videos, names, personal and health data, or other details.
Where information about human subjects or clinical photographs of them are used, informed consent must be documented in the manuscript. Signed copies of the consent forms are required before a paper can be considered for review.
2.9 Use of Generative AI by Authors
2.9.1 Scope
This section refers to the writing process. Authors who use AI or other automated tools in their research, for example for data analysis, describe this in the methods section and remain responsible for the validity of the results.
2.9.2 Permitted Use
Authors who use generative artificial intelligence (AI) and AI-assisted technologies in the writing process should use them only to improve readability and language. These technologies must be applied under human oversight and control. Authors should carefully review and edit the results, because AI can generate output that sounds authoritative but may be incorrect, incomplete, or biased.
2.9.3 AI and Authorship
AI and AI-assisted technologies must not be listed as an author or co-author, nor cited as an author. Authorship implies responsibilities and tasks that can only be attributed to and performed by humans. Generative AI cannot be cited as a source.
2.9.4 Disclosure Requirement
Authors must disclose the use of AI and AI-assisted technologies in the writing process in their manuscript. This statement will appear in the published work. Authors remain ultimately responsible and accountable for the content of their work.
The statement must be added at the end of the core manuscript file, before the reference list, in a separate section entitled "Declaration of Generative AI and AI-assisted technologies in the writing process". It should read as follows:
During the preparation of this work the author(s) used [NAME TOOL/SERVICE] in order to [REASON]. After using this tool/service, the author(s) reviewed and edited the content as needed and take(s) full responsibility for the content of the publication.
This declaration does not apply to basic tools for checking grammar, spelling, references, and the like. If there is nothing to disclose, no statement needs to be added.
2.10 Plagiarism Screening and Consequences of Misconduct
All submissions are screened for text similarity with plagiarism detection software. An editor assesses every similarity report; no decision is made automatically. Submissions in which plagiarism, citation manipulation, fabricated or falsified data, or other misconduct is confirmed are rejected.
In cases of confirmed misconduct, the CE may additionally publish a notice naming the article and the authors responsible and may decline further submissions from the authors responsible to Wohllebe & Ross journals for up to five years, depending on the severity and any repetition of the misconduct. Allegations are investigated as described in the section on ethical concerns, appeals, and complaints and in line with COPE guidance; published articles are handled as described in the section on updates to published articles.
2.11 Data Availability
Authors include a data availability statement indicating whether and where the data supporting the findings can be accessed, or why they cannot be shared (for example, for reasons of confidentiality). Editors and reviewers may request access to the underlying data during review.
3. Responsibilities of Reviewers
3.1 Our Reviewers
Our peer reviewers are primarily published authors of the journal or other relevant experts who have themselves benefited from the expertise of others when their own manuscripts were reviewed. They state their areas of expertise in their journal profile and are assigned manuscripts whose topics match this expertise. Each manuscript is reviewed by at least two external reviewers who are independent of the authors and are not members of the journal's editorial team.
Reviewers must keep their personal and professional information and their fields of expertise in their account up to date. This allows possible conflicts of interest to be ruled out and enables editors to assign them the most suitable manuscripts.
3.2 Role and Ethical Conduct
Peer reviewers play an essential role in ensuring the quality of the journal's scholarly publications, as they contribute to editorial decisions. They must conduct their reviews ethically. The journal expects them to communicate clearly and to deliver objective, fair, unbiased, and timely reviews.
3.3 Confidentiality
Reviewers must neither disclose information obtained from an unpublished work nor use it to their own advantage. No other person may be involved in the review without the journal's permission.
3.4 Conflicts of Interest
Reviewers should agree to review an assigned manuscript only if they are sure that no competing interest (whether personal, financial, intellectual, professional, political, or religious) might prevent them from providing an unbiased and fair review. If a possible conflict of interest exists with regard to the research, the authors, or the funders, they inform the responsible editor and decline the review.
3.5 Review Model
Our journals use double-anonymized peer review to ensure an impartial, fair, and unbiased assessment. The editorial office anonymizes all manuscripts before review; authors do not need to anonymize their files. Reviewers must not attempt to identify the authors. A reviewer who recognizes the authors informs the handling editor, who decides whether the review can continue.
Reviewers remain anonymous to the authors, and review reports are not published with the article. Supplementary material is reviewed together with the manuscript. All article types published by a journal undergo this process. If a journal publishes article types that are not peer reviewed, it states this in its author guidelines, and the articles concerned indicate the type of review they received.
Reviewers must reply to every review invitation, even if they decide not to accept it.
3.6 Conducting the Review
After agreeing to review, the reviewer downloads the anonymized manuscript and evaluates it with the help of the on-screen guidelines, which cover all essential aspects. The reviewer must complete the review form shown on screen and select a recommendation (accept, reject, or revise). An additional free-form review report may optionally be uploaded.
3.7 Suspected Misconduct
Reviewers who suspect research or publication misconduct should report this to the handling editor without conducting any further investigation of their own. The handling editor then investigates the matter further and decides together with the CE which measures to take.
3.8 Use of AI in Peer Review
3.8.1 Confidentiality of Review Materials
Manuscripts submitted for peer review and all associated materials are confidential documents. Reviewers must not upload, submit, or disclose manuscripts, manuscript excerpts, figures, tables, data, review reports, or any other confidential review materials to AI systems or AI-assisted technologies. This applies regardless of whether such systems are publicly accessible, private, locally hosted, or provided by an institution.
3.8.2 Permitted Use
AI-assisted technologies may be used only for ancillary tasks that do not involve disclosing confidential manuscript content. Examples include improving the language and readability of the reviewer's own report, checking grammar and style, and supporting literature discovery and information retrieval. When using AI tools, reviewers should rely on secure and privacy-compliant systems, maintain appropriate human oversight, and critically verify any AI-generated output before incorporating it into their work.
3.8.3 Disclosure
Any use of AI or AI-assisted technologies in connection with the review process that goes beyond spelling and grammar must be disclosed to the journal. Reviewers should briefly describe the tool(s) used and the purpose for which they were used.
3.8.4 Responsibility
Reviewers are solely responsible for the content of their reviews and for all assessments, recommendations, and judgments they communicate to the journal. AI systems cannot replace expert evaluation, critical analysis, scholarly interpretation, or professional judgment. All review comments and recommendations must therefore reflect the reviewer's own independent assessment of the manuscript. Reviewers must not use generative AI to draft or generate their assessment of a manuscript. Reviewers also remain fully responsible for the accuracy, completeness, and appropriateness of any content generated or supported by AI.
3.9 Reviewer Recognition
If a journal grants reviewers benefits, such as discounts on Article Processing Charges, the conditions are stated on the journal's website. Such benefits do not depend on the reviewer's recommendation and do not change any obligation under this policy, in particular regarding conflicts of interest. Articles by reviewers count towards the limit on articles by editors, Editorial Board members, and reviewers.